You Don’t Have to Call It Abuse to Know Something Isn’t Right

Caroline Fithen, MA
Caroline Fithen, MA··8 min read
You Don’t Have to Call It Abuse to Know Something Isn’t Right

There was a long time when I knew something wasn’t right in my relationship without fully understanding what I was experiencing. I knew I didn’t want to be screamed at. I knew being called names wasn’t okay. I knew I shouldn’t be mocked or ridiculed because I didn’t know something, didn’t hear something correctly, or held a different opinion. In the beginning,

In the beginning, I said so. I defended myself. I would say clearly, “Please don’t talk to me like that.” There was a part of me that still trusted my internal alarm system enough to recognize when a line had been crossed.

What often followed, however, wasn’t meaningful change. It was explanation.

I was told I was overreacting or needed to be more understanding. I was encouraged to consider the stress the other person was under, to think about the baby, to keep the peace, to avoid escalating the situation, or simply to let it go. So I tried. I overrode myself for the sake of stability, for the sake of the moment, and for the sake of what I believed was supposed to become a shared life.

The problem was that these moments weren’t isolated. They happened again and again.

Something can begin to shift when your internal alarm is repeatedly met with messages that you are the problem for hearing it. What you once recognized clearly becomes something you second-guess. You begin wondering whether you are too sensitive, too reactive, too demanding, or too difficult. Eventually, you may find yourself increasingly isolated in your own perception of what is happening because no one else seems to be naming what you are experiencing.

When you remain alone in that perception long enough, even certainty can begin to feel fragile.

When Something Feels Wrong but You Don’t Have Language for It

We often talk about unhealthy relationships after someone has acquired the language to describe them. Terms such as emotional abuse, domestic violence and coercive control can be enormously useful. They can help people recognize patterns that previously felt like disconnected incidents.

The difficulty is that many women do not have that language while they are living inside the relationship.

They simply know something feels wrong.

This distinction matters because people sometimes assume a woman will recognize an unhealthy or abusive relationship if she is experiencing one. In reality, she may recognize individual behaviors without understanding the larger pattern. She knows she doesn’t like being yelled at. She knows the name-calling hurts. She knows she dreads bringing up certain subjects. She may even know that she wants the relationship to change.

What she may not understand is what years of adapting to those interactions are doing to her.

When I sought help or explored options during earlier periods of my own life, I didn’t always find answers. Sometimes I didn’t qualify for assistance. Sometimes I was reminded that I had chosen the relationship. Sometimes the message was essentially that I had gotten myself into the situation and would have to figure it out.

So I did what many women do.

I kept figuring it out. I stayed.

I worked, cared for my children, paid bills, managed schedules and tried to anticipate problems before they happened. I adjusted my communication. I accommodated. I tried to find better ways to explain what I needed.

Gradually, I also learned to ask for less.

Ordinary Requests Can Tell Us a Great Deal About a Relationship

When people hear words such as abuse or coercive control, they may picture the most extreme examples. That can unintentionally make it harder to recognize unhealthy dynamics occurring within otherwise ordinary-looking family life.

Sometimes we can learn a great deal about a relationship by paying attention to what happens when someone expresses a normal human need.

Consider the kinds of questions couples and parents ask every day: What time will you be home for dinner? What would you like to do as a family this weekend? Can you watch the baby while I mow the lawn? I’m exhausted; can your family visit tomorrow instead of late tonight? Can you take the baby for a little while so I can shower or take a bath?

None of those requests guarantee agreement. Healthy relationships are not conflict-free, and people do not always respond perfectly. Partners become irritated, misunderstand one another, disappoint each other and sometimes need to revisit conversations.

But disagreement and punishment are not the same thing.

A person should be able to ask a reasonable question without preparing to be screamed at. She should be able to misunderstand something without being mocked. She should be able to express a preference or say no without having her character attacked. A mother should be able to ask the other parent to care for their child without feeling as though she has requested an extraordinary favor.

She should be able to have needs, limits, preferences and opinions while remaining worthy of respect.

When You Begin Evaluating Yourself Instead of the Response

One of the more consequential shifts in an unhealthy dynamic can occur when a person stops evaluating what happened and begins evaluating herself instead.

Rather than asking, “Was that an appropriate response to what I said?” she begins asking, “What did I do to cause that response?”

Maybe I shouldn’t have brought it up. Maybe I’m too sensitive. Maybe I expect too much. Maybe I should have worded it differently. Maybe if I were calmer, kinder, more appreciative or less demanding, these interactions wouldn’t keep happening.

Over time, a person can become remarkably skilled at anticipating reactions. She learns which subjects aren’t worth mentioning. She handles things herself because requesting help feels harder than simply carrying the additional responsibility. She becomes efficient at working around another person’s moods, preferences and behaviors.

From the outside, her life may continue to look relatively ordinary. Inside the home, however, an increasing amount of her behavior may be organized around preventing someone else’s reaction.

This is one reason it can take years to understand what happened. Adaptation often happens incrementally.

You Don’t Need a Label Before You’re Allowed to Pay Attention

A woman does not have to determine whether her relationship meets a particular clinical, legal or social definition before she is allowed to take her experience seriously.

She does not need to diagnose another person. She does not need to immediately decide whether she is staying or leaving. She does not need to convince everyone around her that what she has experienced is “bad enough.”

She can begin by becoming curious about what is happening.

Can I disagree safely? Can I ask questions? Can I say no? Can I make a mistake? Can I ask for help? Can I maintain relationships and interests outside this relationship? Can I express an opinion without preparing myself for ridicule or retaliation? Can both people’s needs exist here?

And perhaps one of the most revealing questions is this: Who have I become in order to keep the peace?

These questions do not dictate what a woman should do next. They give her information with which to make her own decisions.

Sometimes Understanding Comes Later

I understand portions of my own life very differently today than I did while I was living them. At the time, I knew certain things weren’t okay. What I did not fully understand was how those experiences connected or how profoundly years of adapting to them had affected the way I communicated, made decisions and trusted myself.

Some of that understanding came much later through education, professional training, research, reflection and enough distance to recognize patterns I couldn’t fully see while I was busy managing everyday life.

That is one reason language matters so much to me.

Language does not have to tell someone what decision to make. Good language helps us accurately understand what we are observing so that we can make more informed decisions about our own lives.

There can be tremendous power in finally recognizing that a request was not unreasonable, a boundary was legitimate, help was a reasonable thing to need, and mutual respect was not too much to expect.

That recognition may occur long before a woman knows what she wants to do next.

She does not need to know the ending before she is allowed to tell herself the truth about where she is.

Learning to Hear Your Own Voice Again

Healthy relationships require compromise, humility, forgiveness, flexibility and consideration for another person’s needs. But compromise is not the disappearance of one person.

Love does not require someone to become increasingly silent so another person does not become angry. Partnership does not mean one person’s preferences consistently determine what everyone else must accommodate. Respect is not something someone earns by finally discovering the perfect combination of words that prevents another adult from treating her poorly.

Sometimes the first meaningful change is not a dramatic life decision.

Sometimes it is the quieter recognition that I am allowed to have a voice here.

For women who have spent years second-guessing that voice, learning to hear it again can take time. It can also become the beginning of clearer discernment, stronger advocacy and more informed decisions about what comes next.

Caroline Fithen, MA

Written by

Caroline Fithen, MA

Caroline Fithen, MA, provides non-clinical Divorce & Family Strategy Consulting for women navigating difficult relationships, divorce and separation, domestic violence and coercive control, parenting and family transitions, legal and professional systems, and the complicated process of…

View profile

Ready to find a therapist?

Browse licensed therapists in Oregon who match your needs and insurance.

Oregon Cities

Specialties

Therapy Modalities

Alternative Therapies

Oregon Advantage

Oregon leads the nation in access to psychedelic-assisted and integrative mental health therapies.

View all Oregon therapies →